Inside the Black Market of Access

Content by Molly Siegel, MPH and Elizabeth Woodcock, DrPH, MBA, FACMPE, CPC

If your access model only functions because insiders know how to circumvent it, is it really working?

Across academic health systems, there is often an unofficial pathway to care that does not appear on a website, scheduling decision tree, or referral protocol. A physician texts a colleague to ask whether a patient can be squeezed in. An employee knows which practice manager to call. A board member texts a hospital executive. It’s all about knowing someone who knows someone.

Usually, these actions are well intentioned. We see or hear about a friend or colleague struggling to get care – and we try to help. And for people working every day in an extraordinarily challenging industry, knowing how to navigate a health system can understandably feel like one of the few benefits of being on the inside.

The goal should not be to take that benefit away. The bigger questions: Why are connections sometimes necessary in the first place -- and do patients without those connections have an equally navigable path to care?

The unofficial access system

Preferential treatment in healthcare has been discussed in the medical literature for decades, most commonly in the context of “VIP” patients. But VIP status can extend beyond celebrities and major donors. Researchers have described preferential treatment involving physicians, colleagues, family members, and others with connections to the healthcare system.

An article in the AMA Journal of Ethics described how healthcare professionals, aware of inefficiencies within their own systems, may attempt to circumvent those problems for certain patients. The authors cautioned that these actions can create workarounds around normal processes and described situations in which access may be accelerated because of a patient’s status rather than clinical need.¹

That distinction matters. The problem is not appropriate clinical prioritization. Patients should move more quickly when their clinical circumstances require it. The concern arises when the difference between waiting and getting an appointment is simply knowing the right person.

A study examining public attitudes toward preferential access demonstrates the tension. Ninety-five percent of respondents agreed that access to healthcare should be based on need. Yet approximately half said they would contact a friend who was a physician, worked for a physician, or was a hospital administrator to improve their place on a waiting list. Sixteen percent reported having actually done so.²

People can believe strongly in equitable access while also recognizing that relationships may offer another path through the system. In that sense, many health systems have something resembling an informal “black market” for access: not a system built on money or wrongdoing, but one built on relationships, institutional knowledge, favors, escalations, and knowing whom to ask.

Knowing how the system works has value

Connections are only one piece of this. Knowledge itself can create an access advantage. An employee may know that a particular ambulatory practice maintains overbook slots. A clinician may know when a specialist is willing to add a patient. Someone who works in healthcare may understand which words may trigger a timely appointment booking, the direct route to the triage team - or who has the authority to override a scheduling rule.

Patients outside the health system may have none of that information.

Research on social capital and access has examined how relationships, networks, and the resources associated with them can influence an individual's ability to obtain care. A systematic review found substantial interest in this relationship, although definitions and findings varied across studies.³ Research on specialty referrals has also demonstrated the importance of informal professional networks in influencing where patients receive care.⁴

None of this means that every informal interaction is inappropriate. In fact, much of it reflects exactly what we hope stakeholders will do: advocate for people who need help.

For teams working within a health system, there is also a reasonable human element worth acknowledging. Healthcare is demanding work. Clinicians and employees frequently spend their days helping patients navigate complicated systems. Knowing how to navigate that same system for themselves or a family member can feel like a deserved, if largely unspoken, benefit of the job.

Access improvement should not be about taking an appointment away from the nurse, scheduler, physician, medical assistant, or other stakeholder who knows how to find it. It should be about asking why that appointment was so difficult for everyone else to find.

When flexibility creates inequity

The concern becomes more significant when informal knowledge and intervention consistently determine who moves through the system.

A 2023 JAMA Network Open study examined more than 300,000 emergency department encounters and identified situations in which patients received care ahead of people who had arrived earlier or had equal or greater clinical acuity. Researchers described these events as unexplained “queue jumps.” Medicaid-insured, Black, Hispanic or Latino, and Spanish-speaking patients were more likely to be passed over. Black and Hispanic patients and patients insured through Medicare or Medicaid were also less likely to receive care ahead of others.⁵

The researchers could not determine why every deviation occurred, and some may have been clinically appropriate. But the findings demonstrate why health systems should examine what happens when access depends on discretion, advocacy, or deviation from the standard pathway.

Who knows that another pathway exists? Who has someone advocating behind the scenes? And who simply accepts the appointment they were offered?

Workarounds can also hide access problems

There is another consequence of informal access that may be especially important for health system leaders: workarounds can make broken processes appear more functional than they really are.

Consider a patient who needs a specialty appointment but is offered one four months away. The referring clinician recognizes that the delay is inappropriate, texts a specialist, and gets the patient seen the following week. For that patient, the outcome is excellent.

But operationally, the formal access pathway failed because it created too much friction for the patient. An informal pathway rescued the patient. If the health system only sees the successful appointment, the failure that preceded it can disappear.

Now multiply that interaction across clinicians, nurses, schedulers, practice managers, access leaders, and executives. A health system can develop an enormous amount of invisible exception management. Employees become very good at compensating for processes that do not work well. Ironically, their ability to solve individual problems may make the underlying access problem even more difficult to see.

This is the real risk of an access “black market.” Not that people are helping patients, but that the workarounds become so effective and so routine that leaders lose visibility into how difficult the formal pathway has become.

The lesson should not be: stop helping people. The lesson should be: when a workaround consistently produces better access, understand what that workaround is accomplishing and determine whether the formal access model should be redesigned to accomplish the same thing.

Make the front door work

Health system leaders may learn as much from studying exceptions as they do from analyzing averages.

How often are appointments created through escalations, overrides, direct messages, or manual intervention? Why was the patient unable to obtain that appointment through the normal process? Are particular specialties generating a disproportionate number of escalations? Can urgent clinical needs reliably move through formal referral and scheduling pathways? When someone is “squeezed in,” is that unmet demand captured?

Most importantly: what do employees know about obtaining care that patients do not?

A useful test is to imagine two patients with the exact same condition and clinical urgency. One works for your health system and understands it intimately. The other is new to the health system and knows no one inside it.

These two patients do not necessarily need identical experiences. An employee may reasonably benefit from familiarity, relationships, or employee-specific programs. But both patients should have a clear, fair, and navigable opportunity to reach appropriate care.

Improving access does not necessitate closing the back door; it requires making the front door work well enough so that patients don’t need one.

References

  1. Sheffield V, Smith LB. Requests for VIP treatment in pathology: implications for social justice and systems-based practice. AMA Journal of Ethics. 2016;18(8):786-792. 

  2. Friedman SM, Schofield L, Tirkos S. Do as I say, not as I do: a survey of public impressions of queue-jumping and preferential access. European Journal of Emergency Medicine. 2007;14(5):260-264. 

  3. Derose KP, Varda DM. Social capital and health care access: a systematic review. Medical Care Research and Review. 2009;66(3):272-306.

  4. Qureshi N, Berry S, Damberg CL, Gibson B, Popescu I. Referrals and Black-White Coronary Heart Disease Treatment Disparities: A Qualitative Study of Primary Care Physician Perspectives. Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2025;40(15):3572-3580. 

  5. Sangal RB, Su H, Khidir H, et al. Sociodemographic disparities in queue jumping for emergency department care. JAMA Network Open. 2023;6(7):e2326338.